Etsy vs Shopify: Which Platform Is Best for Your Small Business?

Etsy vs Shopify: Which Platform Is Best for Your Small Business?

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. Comparison of Etsy and Shopify 2.1 Pros of Etsy 2.2 Cons of Etsy 2.3 Pros of Shopify 2.4 Cons of Shopify
  3. Fees Comparison 3.1 Etsy Fees 3.2 Shopify Fees
  4. Design and Customization
  5. Driving Traffic to Your Store
  6. International Shipping
  7. Building Credibility and Branding
  8. Customer Support and Policies
  9. Choosing the Right Platform for Your Business
  10. Conclusion

Comparison of Etsy and Shopify

In the world of e-commerce, Etsy and Shopify are two popular platforms that small business owners can utilize to sell their products online. Each platform offers its own set of advantages and disadvantages, so it's important to understand their differences and choose the right one for your business. In this article, we will compare the two platforms, discussing their pros and cons, fees, design and customization options, driving traffic, international shipping, building credibility and branding, customer support, and ultimately help you make an informed decision.

Pros of Etsy

Etsy, known as a marketplace, offers several advantages to small businesses:

  1. Easy Customer Discovery: Etsy's high search engine ranking and built-in customer base make it easier for potential customers to find your products.
  2. Credibility and Established User Base: Being part of Etsy gives your business credibility and allows you to benefit from their established user base. Starting on Etsy can help you build a customer base and gain valuable reviews.
  3. No Startup or Subscription Fees: Unlike many other e-commerce platforms, Etsy does not impose any startup or monthly subscription fees. You only pay fees per sale or listing.
  4. Purchase Protection Program: Etsy's purchase protection program ensures that you are protected as a seller in case of lost or undelivered orders. This program provides a level of security and peace of mind for both buyers and sellers.
  5. Simplicity of International Shipping: Etsy has simplified the process of international shipping by handling taxes and customs charges, allowing sellers to ship worldwide more easily.

Cons of Etsy

While Etsy offers many benefits, it also has a few drawbacks to consider:

  1. Potential Fee Increases: Etsy has the ability to increase fees at any time, which could negatively impact your profit margins. It's important to keep an eye on fee changes and factor them into your pricing strategy.
  2. Limited Control Over Store Design: Etsy provides limited customization options for store designs, making it difficult to truly showcase your brand image in a unique way.
  3. Lack of Control Over Store: As an Etsy seller, you are subject to their rules and policies which means your store could be taken down or your funds could be paused without much explanation or control.
  4. Increased Competition: With its growing popularity, Etsy has seen a significant increase in competition. Standing out among a sea of sellers can be challenging and may require additional effort to gain visibility and sales.

Pros of Shopify

Shopify, on the other hand, offers its own set of advantages that might appeal to small businesses:

  1. Complete Control over Store: Shopify allows you to have complete control over your store design, making it easier to create a branded space that aligns with your business's identity.
  2. Easy to Design and Customize: With user-friendly templates and an intuitive interface, Shopify makes it simple to design and customize your website to suit your brand.
  3. Ability to Build a Mailing List: Unlike Etsy, Shopify allows you to collect customer email addresses and create a mailing list for marketing purposes, helping you stay connected with customers and drive repeat purchases.
  4. More Affordable Fees: While Shopify does have monthly subscription fees, its transaction and payment processing fees tend to be lower, especially for larger businesses.

Cons of Shopify

Despite its advantages, there are a few downsides to consider when using Shopify:

  1. Additional Costs for Features: Some advanced features, such as review functionality and personalization options, might require additional paid apps or customization.
  2. Need to Drive Traffic to Your Store: Unlike Etsy, which has a built-in customer base, attracting traffic to your Shopify store is solely your responsibility. It may require a well-thought-out marketing strategy and efforts in search engine optimization (SEO) to drive traffic to your site.
  3. International Shipping Complexity: Shopify's international shipping setup can be more complex compared to Etsy, where taxes and regulations are already handled for you.

Fees Comparison

Understanding the fees associated with each platform is crucial for small business owners. Here's a breakdown of the fees you can expect from both Etsy and Shopify:

Etsy Fees:

  • Listing Fee: 20 cents per item listed.
  • Auto Renew Fee: After four months, an additional 20 cents per item if not sold.
  • Transaction Fee: 6.5% of the product price and shipping combined.
  • Payment Processing Fee: 3% + 25 cents per sale.
  • Regulatory Operating Fee: 32 cents per sale.
  • Optional Etsy Ads Fee: Additional cost for promoting your listings.

Shopify Fees:

  • Monthly Subscription Fee: Starting from $29 per month (Basic Plan).
  • Payment Processing Fee: Varies depending on the payment service used (2% for Shopify Payments).
  • Additional App Costs: Some advanced features require paid apps which could vary in price.

It's important to note that these fees may vary over time, and it's recommended to always check the latest fee structure for accurate information.

Design and Customization

When it comes to design and customization options, Shopify outshines Etsy with its extensive possibilities. With Shopify, you have the freedom to create a branded space, customize the layout, and highlight your products in a way that reflects your unique style. You can choose from numerous themes, customize colors, fonts, and overall aesthetics to create a visually appealing and cohesive website. On the other hand, while Etsy allows for some customization through banners, logos, and profile pictures, the platform itself has limitations due to its marketplace nature.

Driving Traffic to Your Store

Etsy, being a marketplace platform, offers built-in customer discovery through its high search engine ranking and targeted audience. This makes it relatively easier to attract customers to your Etsy store as compared to driving traffic to your own Shopify store. Shopify relies heavily on your marketing efforts, search engine optimization, social media presence, and other promotional activities to drive traffic. You have to invest time and resources into creating a marketing strategy to reach your target audience and increase visibility.

International Shipping

Etsy simplifies the process of international shipping by providing an international shipping option that includes taxes and customs charges. This makes it easier for sellers to ship worldwide without worrying about additional fees. On the other hand, Shopify requires sellers to set up their own international shipping rates, including taxes and customs charges. While this gives sellers more control over the process, it does add an extra layer of complexity.

Building Credibility and Branding

Etsy offers a sense of credibility and a built-in customer base, as it is a well-established marketplace known for handmade and unique products. Starting on Etsy can help you build trust with customers and gain valuable reviews. Shopify, however, allows you to establish your brand even further by creating a branded website entirely personalized to your business. With your custom domain and complete control over design, you can showcase your brand image and build credibility as an independent online store.

Customer Support and Policies

Both Etsy and Shopify provide customer support, but they differ in terms of policies and control. Etsy has its own support system and policies that sellers must adhere to, while Shopify offers its own set of guidelines and resources. It's important to familiarize yourself with the platform-specific policies, rules, and regulations to ensure a positive selling experience.

Choosing the Right Platform for Your Business

The choice between Etsy and Shopify ultimately depends on your specific business needs and preferences. If you're just starting out and want a platform that offers easy customer discovery and simplicity, Etsy might be the right choice. However, if you desire complete control over your store, extensive customization options, and the ability to drive traffic through your marketing efforts, Shopify is worth considering. It's important to evaluate the pros and cons of each platform, consider your long-term goals, and choose the platform that aligns best with your business strategy.


In conclusion, Etsy and Shopify are both viable e-commerce platforms, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. Etsy offers built-in customer discovery, credibility, and simplicity, while Shopify allows for complete control, extensive customization, and the ability to grow and scale your business. It's crucial to carefully evaluate your business needs, consider the key factors discussed in this article, and choose the platform that best suits your goals and ambitions. Remember, no platform is perfect, and it's possible to use both Etsy and Shopify to maximize your online presence.

I am a shopify merchant, I am opening several shopify stores. I use ppspy to find Shopify stores and track competitor stores. PPSPY really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to PPSPY's service, I hope more people can like PPSPY! — Ecomvy

Join PPSPY to find the shopify store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
Shopify Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial