Maximize Your Etsy Success with Expert Tips and Strategies

Maximize Your Etsy Success with Expert Tips and Strategies

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. How to Ask Customers for Reviews
  3. The Best SEO Tools for Etsy
  4. Strategies for Regrouping and Avoiding Burnout
  5. Should You Close or Start Listing in a Dormant Etsy Shop?
  6. Expanding Your Crochet Business to Include Large Items
  7. Scaling Your Ecommerce Brand with Shopify and Amazon
  8. Balancing Work and Taking Time Off as an Etsy Seller
  9. Selling Large Oil and Acrylic Paintings on Etsy
  10. Managing Multiple Etsy Shops

Article: How to Succeed as an Etsy Seller: Tips from a Million-Dollar Seller

As an experienced Etsy seller with over seven years of success and $1.5 million in revenue, I have learned valuable strategies for scaling an Etsy business to a multi-six-figure level. In this article, I will share my insights and tips on various aspects of running a successful Etsy shop. From asking customers for reviews to expanding your product range and managing multiple shops, these tips will help you optimize your Etsy business and achieve your financial goals.

1. How to Ask Customers for Reviews

One of the keys to gaining positive reviews on Etsy is providing exceptional customer service. Rather than directly asking customers for reviews, focus on creating such a great buying experience that they willingly leave reviews on their own. This can be achieved through personalized messages, branded thank-you notes, and exceeding customer expectations. However, you can subtly prompt customers to leave a review by including a gentle reminder in your post-sale communication. For example, a little note with a friendly message like "If you're happy with your purchase, we would appreciate your feedback in the form of a review!" can encourage customers to share their positive experiences.


  • Encourages organic reviews without coming across as pushy.
  • Fosters a positive customer experience by exceeding expectations.
  • Builds trust and credibility by showcasing genuine customer feedback.


  • May not result in immediate reviews from all customers.
  • Requires consistent effort and attention to detail in customer service.

2. The Best SEO Tools for Etsy

While Etsy provides essential SEO tools, supplementing them with a free version of eRank can further enhance your shop's visibility. This powerful combination allows you to optimize your listings and increase your chances of appearing in relevant search results. With eRank, you can conduct keyword research, track your shop's performance, and gain insights into competitor strategies. By leveraging these tools effectively, you can enhance your shop's SEO, attract more targeted traffic, and increase your chances of making sales.


  • Access to additional features beyond Etsy's built-in SEO tools.
  • Comprehensive keyword research capabilities.
  • Ability to monitor and improve your shop's performance.


  • Learning curve for utilizing eRank effectively.
  • May require additional time and effort for optimization.

3. Strategies for Regrouping and Avoiding Burnout

As an Etsy seller, it's essential to prioritize self-care and avoid burnout. When you feel overwhelmed or exhausted, taking steps to regroup is crucial. Consider incorporating the following strategies:

  1. Prioritize Sleep: Aim for adequate rest by setting aside time for extra sleep.
  2. Seek Inspiration: Engage in activities that uplift you, such as reading devotionals or listening to inspirational speeches or podcasts.
  3. Focus on High-Impact Tasks: Identify tasks that contribute directly to your business's growth and prioritize them over low-impact, busy work.
  4. Delegate Household Chores: Outsource tasks that consume your time and energy, such as hiring a cleaning service.
  5. Learn to Say No: Set boundaries and decline opportunities that drain your energy or don't align with your goals.

By implementing these strategies, you can recharge and maintain motivation while effectively managing your business.


  • Helps prevent burnout and maintain enthusiasm.
  • Increases productivity by focusing on high-impact tasks.
  • Creates a healthy work-life balance.


  • Requires discipline and time management skills.
  • Can be challenging to delegate tasks initially.

4. Should You Close or Start Listing in a Dormant Etsy Shop?

If you have a dormant Etsy shop with no sales or reviews, it may be advantageous to open a new shop instead of reviving the inactive one. Etsy gives a boost to new shops, which can provide an advantage in gaining visibility and attracting customers. Therefore, if your dormant shop has no sales and reviews, it's recommended to open a new shop to take advantage of Etsy's fresh start.


  • Utilizes Etsy's boost for new shops.
  • Allows for a fresh start with improved visibility.
  • Avoids potential setbacks associated with reviving a dormant shop.


  • Requires setting up a new shop and rebuilding your listings.
  • May result in temporary loss of visibility if the dormant shop has gained some organic traffic.

5. Expanding Your Crochet Business to Include Large Items

Expanding your crochet business to include large items like clothing can be a profitable venture. However, considering the time-intensive nature of creating large items, careful planning is necessary. Instead of solely focusing on crocheted clothing, explore the possibility of combining crochet work with alterations. For example, consider altering pre-made items like denim jackets with crochet applique details. This allows you to offer unique, higher-priced items without dedicating excessive hours to each piece. By diversifying your product range in this way, you can attract more customers and increase your average order value.


  • Expands your target audience and potential customer base.
  • Offers the opportunity to create unique, higher-priced items.
  • Maximizes efficiency by combining crochet work with alterations.


  • Requires careful market research to identify profitable niches.
  • May involve additional skill acquisition or collaboration with other artisans.

6. Scaling Your Ecommerce Brand with Shopify and Amazon

While Etsy is an excellent platform for starting and growing an ecommerce business, expanding to other channels like Shopify and Amazon can further enhance your brand's reach and revenue potential. Integrating Shopify allows you to have a standalone website and leverage Etsy's traffic to drive visitors to your own website. On the other hand, Amazon offers access to a massive customer base, but it requires more significant investment and a different business model. It's crucial to carefully consider your resources and long-term goals before venturing into these additional platforms.


  • Diversifies your sales channels and customer base.
  • Provides the opportunity to build a standalone brand outside of Etsy.
  • Amazon's immense reach can help you tap into a larger market.


  • Requires additional resources, time, and investment.
  • Involves navigating different rules and strategies on each platform.

7. Balancing Work and Taking Time Off as an Etsy Seller

Maintaining a healthy work-life balance is important as an Etsy seller. While it may initially require intense dedication, achieving financial freedom through your business allows for flexibility in how you allocate your time. Taking planned days off can be beneficial for recharging and preventing burnout, but it's important to find a balance that aligns with your goals. Providing excellent customer service while setting boundaries for personal time is key. Remember, financial freedom means having the freedom to choose how you spend your time!


  • Offers flexibility in managing your time.
  • Prevents burnout and enhances overall well-being.
  • Enables you to prioritize personal and family commitments.


  • May require careful planning and boundaries to ensure business continuity.
  • Initial period of intensive work to establish financial stability.

8. Selling Large Oil and Acrylic Paintings on Etsy

Selling large oil and acrylic paintings on Etsy can be a rewarding endeavor, despite the perception of saturation in the art category. To succeed, it's crucial to identify your unique selling proposition and target a specific niche within the art market. Consider the subject matter, aesthetic style, and potential gaps in existing offerings. By offering something distinctive and meeting the needs of a specific customer base, you can stand out in a seemingly saturated market. Market your artwork to appeal to the premium customer segment and highlight the quality and craftsmanship behind your pieces.


  • Opportunities to showcase unique, large-scale art.
  • Tap into Etsy's art-loving customer base.
  • Potential to attract premium customers and command higher prices.


  • Requires thorough market research and positioning.
  • Challenges of shipping large and fragile artworks.

9. Managing Multiple Etsy Shops

Having multiple Etsy shops can be a viable strategy to target different niches or offer a diverse product range. However, efficient management is crucial to avoid spreading yourself too thin. Consider factors such as time investment, inventory management, and potential crossover between shops. Having a clear plan and system to streamline operations can help you effectively manage multiple shops without sacrificing quality or customer experience.


  • Allows for targeted marketing and niche-specific branding.
  • Offers flexibility to explore different product categories.
  • Increases revenue potential by catering to diverse customer segments.


  • Requires careful organization and time management.
  • Potential for inventory and logistical challenges.


  • Learn effective strategies for asking customers for reviews without being pushy.
  • Explore free SEO tools like eRank to optimize your Etsy listings.
  • Implement strategies to overcome burnout and regroup effectively.
  • Consider opening a new shop if a dormant shop has no sales or reviews.
  • Diversify your crochet business by incorporating large, altered items.
  • Understand the potential of scaling your business with Shopify and Amazon.
  • Find a balance between work and taking time off to maintain well-being.
  • Stand out in the art market by targeting specific niches and emphasizing quality.
  • Learn tips for successfully managing multiple Etsy shops.


Q: Is it okay to ask customers for reviews on Etsy? A: While it's best not to blatantly ask for reviews, focusing on providing an exceptional customer experience can naturally encourage customers to leave reviews.

Q: What are the best SEO tools for Etsy? A: Etsy's built-in SEO tools are sufficient, but supplementing them with eRank can provide additional insights and optimization opportunities.

Q: How can I avoid burnout as an Etsy seller? A: Prioritize self-care, focus on high-impact tasks, delegate non-essential tasks, and establish boundaries to prevent burnout and stay motivated.

Q: Should I close a dormant Etsy shop or start listing in it? A: If a dormant shop has no sales or reviews, it's recommended to open a new shop to take advantage of Etsy's new shop boost.

Q: Can I create premium brands with print-on-demand products on Etsy? A: Yes, it's possible to create premium brands with print-on-demand products by targeting the right customer segments and focusing on quality and aesthetics.

Q: How can I scale my Etsy business with Shopify and Amazon? A: Etsy can be used as a stepping stone to drive traffic to your standalone Shopify website. Amazon requires more investment and a different business model but offers access to a vast customer base.

Q: Is it important to have a day off as an Etsy seller? A: While it's essential to prioritize self-care, taking a day off is a personal choice. Financial freedom allows you to decide how you spend your time.

Q: How can I succeed in selling large art on Etsy? A: Identify your unique selling proposition, target a specific niche, and market your art to appeal to premium customers.

Q: Is it possible to manage multiple Etsy shops successfully? A: Managing multiple shops can be effective if you have a clear plan, streamline operations, and avoid spreading yourself too thin with inventory and logistics.

Q: Can I resell my Etsy shop to others? A: No, it is not legal to resell an Etsy shop. It is recommended to build and grow your own shop organically.

I am a shopify merchant, I am opening several shopify stores. I use ppspy to find Shopify stores and track competitor stores. PPSPY really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to PPSPY's service, I hope more people can like PPSPY! — Ecomvy

Join PPSPY to find the shopify store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
Shopify Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial