The Challenges of Shopify and Print-on-Demand: Lessons Learned

The Challenges of Shopify and Print-on-Demand: Lessons Learned

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. My Journey with Shopify and Print-on-Demand
  3. Why I Decided to Close My Shopify Store
  4. The Challenges of Shopify and Print-on-Demand 4.1. Tax Issues 4.2. Managing Multiple Online Stores 4.3. Customer Service Challenges 4.4. Cost per Action for Facebook Ads
  5. The Importance of Passion and Focus
  6. Considerations for Selling T-Shirts with Print-on-Demand 6.1. Low Profit Margins of T-Shirts 6.2. Alternative High-Profit Margin Products 6.3. Influencer Marketing and Affiliate Marketing 6.4. Using Instagram for Organic Traffic 6.5. Exploring TikTok Ads and Videos
  7. Lessons Learned and Advice for Starting a Shopify and Print-on-Demand Store
  8. Conclusion

My Journey with Shopify and Print-on-Demand

In 2021, I made the decision to venture into the world of e-commerce by opening a Shopify store and utilizing print-on-demand services. It seemed like a promising opportunity to turn my best-selling items and niche into a profitable online business. Over the course of six months, I dedicated myself to growing my store and learning the ins and outs of Shopify. However, despite some initial success, I ultimately made the difficult decision to close down my Shopify and print-on-demand store. This is the story that I don't often share, but I believe it's important to shed light on the challenges and realities of running such a business.

Why I Decided to Close My Shopify Store

There were several reasons that led to my decision to close my Shopify store. Firstly, being a solo entrepreneur, I found it overwhelming to manage multiple online stores simultaneously. In addition to my Shopify store, I also had an Etsy store and a YouTube channel dedicated to teaching others about print-on-demand. It became clear to me that I couldn't effectively handle all these responsibilities on my own, especially as my YouTube channel grew in popularity.

Another factor in my decision was the high level of customer service issues I faced, particularly the integration problems between my Shopify store and print-on-demand provider. As a one-person operation, it became increasingly difficult to handle these issues and meet the expectations of my customers. The workload became unmanageable, and it impacted the overall success and profitability of my store.

Furthermore, I realized that my true passion lay in teaching others about print-on-demand rather than running a Shopify store. While I enjoyed the process of learning Shopify and marketing through platforms like Facebook and Instagram, I found greater satisfaction in helping individuals set up their own businesses in the print-on-demand industry. This realization prompted me to reevaluate my priorities and shift my focus toward my YouTube channel and teaching endeavors.

The Challenges of Shopify and Print-on-Demand

During my journey with Shopify and print-on-demand, I encountered several challenges that are often overlooked by those discussing the business model. One of the major challenges was related to taxes. Unlike Etsy, which streamlined the tax remittance process for sellers, Shopify required me to handle tax registration and collection for every state in which I generated sales. This added complexity and time-consuming task required me to find an automated tax system to ensure compliance.

Managing multiple online stores, each with its own distinct set of responsibilities, was another obstacle I faced. While Shopify offered more flexibility and opportunities for customization, it also meant additional work and attention to detail. Balancing the demands of multiple platforms, customer inquiries, and order fulfillment became increasingly burdensome as my workload grew.

Customer service issues were a recurring problem that impacted my overall experience with Shopify and print-on-demand. Dealing with integration problems and resolving customer complaints took a toll on both my time and energy. It became apparent that providing satisfactory customer service on top of other responsibilities was a significant challenge for a solo entrepreneur like myself.

Lastly, the cost per action for Facebook ads, particularly for t-shirts, presented a significant hurdle. The low-profit margins associated with t-shirts meant that advertising costs often exceeded the potential earnings. While there were occasional profitable days, sustaining a profitable business solely with t-shirts proved to be an ongoing struggle. This led me to explore alternative marketing strategies, such as influencer and affiliate marketing, and focus on higher-profit margin products.

The Importance of Passion and Focus

Closing down my Shopify store allowed me to realign my focus with my true passions. It taught me the importance of identifying where my passion lies and dedicating my efforts accordingly. In this case, my passion for teaching print-on-demand surpassed my desire to run a Shopify store. Recognizing this allowed me to invest more time and energy into creating educational content and supporting others in their print-on-demand endeavors.

While the experience with Shopify and print-on-demand presented its fair share of challenges, it also provided valuable lessons and insights. It is essential for aspiring entrepreneurs to carefully evaluate their interests, strengths, and long-term goals before embarking on a specific business model. Passion and focus are crucial elements that contribute to sustained motivation and success in any venture.

Considerations for Selling T-Shirts with Print-on-Demand

T-shirts are a popular product choice for many entrepreneurs entering the print-on-demand business. However, it is important to consider several factors before solely focusing on selling t-shirts through Shopify.

Firstly, t-shirts typically have lower profit margins compared to other products, such as jewelry or hoodies. The cost per action for Facebook ads can often surpass the potential profit from a single t-shirt sale. It is essential to evaluate whether the profit margins align with your desired financial goals.

Exploring alternative high-profit margin products is worth considering. Items like jewelry or higher-end clothing items like sweatshirts and hoodies can offer more significant profit potential. By diversifying your product offerings, you can balance out the impact of lower-profit products like t-shirts.

Influencer marketing and affiliate marketing can be effective strategies for promoting your print-on-demand products. Collaborating with influencers who align with your brand and target audience can generate organic traffic and boost sales. Additionally, leveraging affiliate marketing can expand your reach and drive more conversions.

Utilizing Instagram for organic traffic is another avenue worth exploring. Building a following on Instagram and engaging with your audience through compelling content can lead to increased brand awareness and direct sales. Creating an aesthetically appealing feed and actively engaging with your followers can help establish a loyal customer base.

Considering the rising popularity of TikTok, incorporating TikTok ads and videos into your marketing strategy can be advantageous. With TikTok's potential for viral content, one successful video can significantly boost your visibility and attract a large number of followers and potential customers.

Lessons Learned and Advice for Starting a Shopify and Print-on-Demand Store

Based on my experiences, there are several key lessons and advice that I would offer to anyone considering starting a Shopify and print-on-demand store:

  1. Take into account the challenges and potential limitations of the Shopify and print-on-demand business model, such as tax management, customer service, and marketing costs.
  2. Assess your passion and interest in the chosen niche and products. Ensure that you are enthusiastic about the products you will be selling and the industry you will be operating in.
  3. Consider the profit margins and market demand for the products you intend to sell. Diversify your product offerings to include higher-profit margin items and explore marketing strategies that align with those products.
  4. Focus on building organic traffic through social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok. Establishing a loyal customer base and engaging with your audience can lead to sustainable growth.
  5. Learn from the experiences and mistakes of other entrepreneurs in the industry. Engage with online communities, attend webinars and conferences, and continuously educate yourself on the latest strategies and trends.


Closing down my Shopify and print-on-demand store was a tough decision, but ultimately the right one for me. The challenges and limitations of running the business, coupled with my passion for teaching and focusing on other aspects of the print-on-demand industry, led me to reevaluate my priorities. Through this journey, I learned valuable lessons about identifying passion, managing multiple online stores, and choosing high-profit margin products. Starting a Shopify and print-on-demand store can be a rewarding endeavor if approached with careful consideration, adaptability, and a clear understanding of personal goals and interests.

I am a shopify merchant, I am opening several shopify stores. I use ppspy to find Shopify stores and track competitor stores. PPSPY really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to PPSPY's service, I hope more people can like PPSPY! — Ecomvy

Join PPSPY to find the shopify store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
Shopify Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial