Choosing Between Etsy and Shopify for Selling Your Jewelry

Choosing Between Etsy and Shopify for Selling Your Jewelry

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Setting Up Shop
  3. Branding
  4. Marketing
  5. Support
  6. Cost
  7. Conclusion

Should You Sell on Etsy or Your Own Website?

When it comes to selling jewelry online, one of the biggest decisions you'll have to make is whether to sell on Etsy or create your own website. Both options have their pros and cons, and it's important to carefully consider each before making a decision. In this article, we'll explore the key factors to consider when choosing between Etsy and your own website for selling jewelry.

1. Introduction

Selling jewelry online can be overwhelming, especially when deciding between Etsy and your own website. In this article, we'll dive deep into the pros and cons of both options to help you make the right decision for your jewelry business.

2. Setting Up Shop

2.1 Etsy

Setting up shop on Etsy is relatively simple, especially for new jewelry makers or designers. Etsy provides an easy-to-use platform where you can create product listings, set prices, upload photos, and manage shipping. The marketplace already has a built-in audience, making it easier for new sellers to get started and test the waters.

2.2 Your Own Website

If you choose to sell on your own website, platforms like Shopify offer a wide range of templates to choose from. These templates provide a good foundation for setting up your online store, allowing you to customize the layout, colors, and fonts to match your brand. While setting up shop may require a bit more effort, Shopify offers tutorials and support to guide you through the process.

3. Branding

3.1 Etsy

On Etsy, branding is limited to uploading your logo and filling in basic information. The platform has its own branding, which can limit your ability to stand out from other sellers. Your storefront will look similar to others on Etsy, making it challenging to convey a unique brand identity.

3.2 Your Own Website

Having your own website provides more control over your brand. You can create a custom design, choose specific colors and fonts, and curate a space that represents your brand effectively. This flexibility allows you to showcase your brand's story and connect with customers on a deeper level. It also makes it easier for customers to recommend and remember your brand, improving word-of-mouth marketing.

4. Marketing

4.1 Etsy

Etsy has built-in marketing and a large user base, which can benefit new sellers. The platform has a trusted reputation and attracts millions of shoppers yearly. However, competition for attention is high, as similar products from other sellers are displayed alongside your listings. The focus on price competition may lead to undercutting, making it difficult to maintain profit margins.

4.2 Your Own Website

Marketing on your own website requires more initiative, as you'll need to drive traffic and build brand awareness. However, this also means having more control over your marketing strategies. You can use email marketing to reach potential customers, capture email addresses, and create customized email sequences to nurture leads. With fewer distractions from competitors, your website allows customers to focus solely on your products and brand.

5. Support

Both Etsy and Shopify offer support for sellers, although the level of support may differ.

6. Cost

There are cost considerations for both Etsy and having your own website.

7. Conclusion

Choosing between Etsy and your own website requires careful consideration of the pros and cons. While Etsy provides an established marketplace, having your own website gives you more control over branding, marketing, and customer experience. Assess your business goals and consider the factors discussed in this article to make the best decision for your jewelry business.


  • Selling jewelry online involves choosing between Etsy and your own website.
  • Etsy provides an easy setup process, but limits branding opportunities.
  • Having your own website allows for more control over your brand and customer experience.
  • Etsy offers built-in marketing and customer base, but competition can lead to price undercutting.
  • Your own website requires more proactive marketing but offers more control and potential for growth.
  • Consider factors like support and cost when making your decision.


Q: Is it easier to set up shop on Etsy or create my own website? A: Setting up shop on Etsy is relatively simple and straightforward. Creating your own website using platforms like Shopify requires more effort but offers more customization options.

Q: Can I customize the branding on Etsy? A: While you can upload your logo on Etsy, the platform has its own branding that appears throughout your storefront. This limits the ability to create a unique branded experience.

Q: How does marketing differ between Etsy and my own website? A: Etsy has built-in marketing and a large user base. However, competition for attention and price undercutting can make it challenging to stand out. On your own website, you have more control over marketing strategies and can capture customer emails for targeted campaigns.

Q: Which option is more cost-effective? A: Etsy charges transaction and listing fees, while having your own website comes with a monthly fee. The overall cost will depend on factors like the number of listings and sales volume.

Q: Can I get support for both options? A: Both Etsy and Shopify provide support for sellers. Etsy has an in-built support team, while Shopify offers tutorials, troubleshooters, and the option to hire Shopify experts for assistance.

I am a shopify merchant, I am opening several shopify stores. I use ppspy to find Shopify stores and track competitor stores. PPSPY really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to PPSPY's service, I hope more people can like PPSPY! — Ecomvy

Join PPSPY to find the shopify store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
Shopify Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial